Check Out our Happy Hour and Event Day Specials!
Fresh From Our Shelves to Your Door
- Store
- /
- Gourmet Pantry
Gourmet Pantry
to
Featured
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Name: A-Z
Name: Z-A
102 Products

Garlic Herb Dipping Sauce
From our kitchen to your table, we take the work out of concocting a dipping oil. Our Traditional Garlic-Herb Dipping Sauce will delight all of your senses. We combine our fresh and fruity Olive Oil and our Traditional Aged Balsamic Vinegar with a selection of our favorite herbs and spices to create this irresistible dipping sauce. Slightly sweet and fruity, with a rich bite and a garlicky finish, it will leave your mouth asking for more. So versatile, you can use this as a salad dressing and marinade.$18.00
Garlic Pizza Dipping Oil
Inspired by classic recipes, our premium extra virgin olive oil is infused with aromatic garlic, onion and spices, plus cracked red pepper flakes for a hint of heat. Drizzle on pizza and pasta, use it as a dip for artisan breads – or to enhance fresh-baked garlic bread.$18.00
Parmesan Dipping Sauce
We combine fresh and fruity Olive Oil and Italian Parmesan cheese with some of our favorite herbs to create this delightful dipping sauce. For all cheese lovers it will add exceptional flavor to your cooking. So versatile, you can use this as a salad dressing and marinade.$18.00
Tuscan Herb Dipping Oil
Our Tuscan Herb Dipping Oil takes the hassle out of making your own dipping oil or sauce. The rich flavors will remind you of the comfort of authentic Mediterranean cooking. We combine our fresh and fruity Olive Oil with a selection of fresh herbs: basil, oregano, and rosemary abound.$18.00
Housemade Dressings Blood-Orange Pom
Salads should not be boring! Nor should any food for that matter. If you are looking for the punch of a citrus dressing with the light sweetness of a perfectly paired sweet balsamic, this blend is for you. Great for marinating chicken, pork, fish, drizzle over a summer salad or a salty cheese on a charcuterie board. Our housemade dressings take the guesswork out of the measuring, the blending and seasonings. Shelf stable, perfectly blended and paired.$18.00
Housemade Dressings Garlic Herb Dark
Our fresh Garlic Herb EVOO married with our rich, dark Traditional Balsamic Vinegar and steeping with a light Italian flair of our Tuscan Herb Seasoning, the hint of zest from our Lemon Herb Seasoning to make this the most perfect dressing, dipping, all around everything marinade...you might want to drink from the bottle.$18.00
Housemade Dressings La Cucina
The La Cucina is reminiscent of your grandmothers kitchen, a delicious merriment of our Coratina EVOO & bright Cranberry-Pear Balsamic; peppery, sweet and crisp. Our housemade dressings take the guesswork out of the measuring, the blending and seasonings. Shelf stable, perfectly blended and paired.$22.00
Housemade Dressings Thai Chili-Garlic
A spicy-sweet blend perfect for dipping, dressings, marinating and so much more. The fiery pop of heat from our Thai Chili olive oil blended with the sweetness of our Garlic (white) Balsamic. Our housemade dressings take the guesswork out of the measuring, the blending and seasonings. Shelf stable, perfectly blended and paired.$18.00
Fat Cat - Bacon Flavored Sriracha
$12.00
Fat Cat - Everyday Green
Everyday Green Jalapeno Hot Sauce by Fat Cat Gourmet is a mild green chili table condiment created specifically to complement a wide variety of foods. Use it anywhere you want to taste the fresh snap of green chilies!$9.00
Fat Cat - Florida
Florida Sauce CItrus and Datil Pepper Blend by Fat Cat Gourmet is a one-of-a-kind condiment that represents the spirit of the Sunshine State. Featuring ingredients indicative of Florida’s agriculture, this sauce combines tangy, bitter and sour citrus (orange, grapefruit and key lime), sweet orange blossom honey and punchy datil pepper — a unique chili that thrives in St. Augustine. Flip flops and sunglasses not required (but recommended).$9.00
Fat Cat - Habanero
Mexican-Style Habanero Hot Sauce by Fat Cat Gourmet takes a decidedly Mexican approach to the orange habanero, focusing more on the pepper’s fruity flavor than its intense heat. Don’t get us wrong: This is still darned hot stuff, but it’s also savory and sweet and lets you appreciate the citrus and apricot notes typically found in the flavor of the habanero. Winner of the Golden Chile (1st Place) in the 2014 Fiery Foods Challenge for Habanero Sauce.$9.00
Fat Cat - Peach Bourbon
The sleepy Southern charms of Savannah, Georgia inspired Fat Cat Gourmet's Peach Maple Bourbon Hot Sauce and Glaze, a sweet and savory concoction that blends ripe peaches, maple syrup, bourbon whiskey, spices and chilies into a delicious and versatile condiment. It's the cat's meow, y'all.$9.00
Fat Cat - Purry Purry
Purry-Purry Sauce is Fat Cat Gourmet's version of the classic South African condiment Piri-Piri Sauce (or Peri Peri Sauce, as it's known in some circles)! A magical Thai-Asian-inspired mix of caramelized onions, garlic, ginger, tomatoes and peri-peri peppers — small red chilies that pack some powerful back heat. Winner of the 2012 Hot Pepper Award for Best Ethnic Sauce, winner of the 2013 Cajun Hot Sauce Festival Award for Best African Sauce, and winner of the 2013 Hot Pepper Award for Best Exotic Pepper Sauce.$9.00
Fat Cat - Serrano
The Florida Strawberry Festival, held each year in Plant City, inspired Strawberry Serrano Hot Sauce by Fat Cat Gourmet. This sweet-heat fruit-and-chili combination features a unique blend of sun-ripened strawberries and spicy serrano peppers. Named by CNN as one of the "Best Hot Sauces You Can Buy Online" Named by "Good Mythical Morning" as the "Best Fruit Hot Sauce"$9.00War Paint - Orange Papaya
$14.00War Paint - Pineapple Straw Habanero
$14.00
War Paint - Cuke Habanero
$14.00War Paint - Mango Habanero
$14.00Peach Bourbon Jam
$5.50 - $10.00Fig Jam
$8.00 - $10.00Merlot Wine Jam
$5.50 - $10.00
Meyer Lemon Ginger Jam
A delightfully refreshing burst of citrus complements the warm, spicy ginger in this delicious jam. A sweet kick to a traditional lemon curd style jam.$8.00 - $10.00Pineapple Mango Habanero Jam
$5.50 - $10.00
Strawberry Vanilla Jam
Who doesn’t have a jar of strawberry jam in their fridge? To make this one special we shortened cooking times to preserve freshness and wholeness of the fruit. Then we added real vanilla bean to elevate the flavor. Not too sweet and not too short on being extraordinary.$5.50 - $10.00
Apricot Jalapeno Jam
$10.00
Blackberry Raspberry Cardamom Jam
$10.00
Caramelized Onion Balsamic Jam
$10.00
Fig & Onion Savory Jam
$10.00
Hot Seven Pepper Jam
$10.00
Jam Gift Tube
A collection of our most popular and favorite flavors of gourmet jams, neatly packaged in a gift tube. Ready for gifting or stuffing a stocking.$17.00
Amber Beer Mustard
Our Amber Beer Mustard has the characteristic of a true amber ale with its subtle “maltiness” and rich color. Sweet, malt extracts balance the bitter notes for a smooth mustard that perfectly complements your best cured meats or savory sausage.$5.50 - $10.00
Jalapeno Whiskey Mustard
$5.50 - $10.00
Stoneground Mustard
$5.50 - $10.00
Cabernet Garlic Mustard
$10.00
Lemon Dill Mustard
$10.00
Mustard Gift Tube
Our most popular and favorite mustard flavors neatly packaged in a gift tube.$17.00
Sweet and Spicy Mustard - 2oz
$5.50
Garlic Stuffed Olives
Plump, Meaty Sevillano Olives Hand-Stuffed with California Garlic Indulge your palate in the ultimate savory delicacy with our premium Garlic Stuffed Green Olives. Packaged in a generous 10oz jar, this exceptional gourmet treat features extra-large, prized Sevillano olives, celebrated worldwide for their crisp, firm texture and famously meaty bite. Each individual olive is meticulously selected at the peak of plumpness and carefully hand-stuffed with a whole, crisp California garlic clove that has been lightly marinated to mellow its sharp bite while preserving its robust flavor. Cured in a traditional, perfectly balanced brine, these succulent green olives deliver an explosion of rich, salty, and savory goodness that fills your mouth with a deeply satisfying punch of garlicky flavor from the very first bite.$11.00
Herbed Medley Olives
$11.00
Herbs De Provence Olives
$9.00
Jalapeno Stuffed Olives
$11.00
Applewood Smoked Sea Salt
$9.00
Bacon Smoked Sea Salt
$6.00
Black Truffle Sea Salt
$14.00
Honey Truffle Sea Salt
$10.00
Le Sel Gris
$5.00
Lime Fresco Sea Salt
$9.00
Red Alderwood Smoked Sea Salt
$6.00
Tuscan Herb Sea Salt
$9.00
Butter Chicken Simmer Sauce
$13.00
Calabrian Chile Vodka Pasta Sauce
$13.00
Creamy Vodka Sauce
$13.00
Dark Chocolate Sauce
$11.00
Korean BBQ Sauce
$13.00
Pumpkin Spice Caramel Sauce
$13.00Raspberry Chipotle BBQ Sauce
$13.00
Red Enchilada Sauce
$13.00
Roasted Garlic Chipotle Salsa
$11.00
Salsa Verde Simmer Sauce
$13.00Sea Salt Caramel Sauce
$0
Sesame Ginger Teriyaki
$13.00
Smokey Bourbon BBQ Sauce
$13.00
Thai Coconut Red Curry Sauce
$13.00
Tomato Basil Pasta Sauce
$13.00
Tuscan Sun-Dried Tomato Pasta Sauce
$13.00
Fat Cat - Cranberry Habanero Relish
Cranberry Habanero Relish by Fat Cat Gourmet mixes the comforting holiday flavors of tangy cranberries and citrus-y orange with the punch of orange habaneros, creating a fun spin on a classic American condiment. Eat by the spoonful or spread over your favorite sandwich or as your new Cranberry spread at Thanksgiving.$12.00
BBQ & Roasting Rub
$9.00
Black Truffle Fusion Seasoning
$12.00
Chili Lime Seasoning
$9.00
Coastal Harvest Seasoning
$8.00
Fat Cat - Feline Fiesta Seasoning
$9.00
Fat Cat - Meow-Minara
$9.00
Firenze Fusion
$6.00
Fish & Seafood Seasoning
$9.00
Garlic Burst Seasoning
$6.00
Korean BBQ Seasoning
$6.00
Lemon Herb Seasoning
A blend of tangy citrus and fragrant herbs, this delicate seasoning enhances the natural flavors of chicken, fish and seafood. This versatile blend makes a great addition to any seasonal vegetables and salads. Try it for dips, sauces, a tangy vinaigrette and so much more!$9.00
Provencal Seasoning
$8.00
Tuscan Herb Seasonings
$9.00
Garlic Burst - Salt Free
Enjoy our Garlic Burst sans salt! Perfect for our folks on the DASH Diet or watching total sodium intake.$6.00
Crown & Carver Roast Rub
Hearty, old-world flavor right in your kitchen. Coat roasts liberally before cooking and use the remaining juices for a perfect homemade gravy. Wonderful for root vegetables, asparagus, or sprinkle over mashed potatoes.$6.00
Roasted Espresso Sugar
$6.00
Salted Caramel Monk Fruit Sweetener
$7.00
Wild Blueberry Monk Fruit Sweetener
$7.00
Wild Blueberry Sugar
$6.00Farmhouse Olive Tapenade
$12.00Fig & Olive Tapenade
$12.00Green Olive Tapenade
$5.50Kalamata & Caper Tapenade
$5.50 - $12.00
Parmesan Artichoke Tapenade
$5.50 - $12.00
Porcini Truffle Tapenade
Our Porcini & Truffle tapenade is the mushroom lovers dream come true. Perfect on pasta, poultry, sandwiches, bruschetta and on an appetizer platter. This decadent tapenade is the epitome of "caviar of the olive world."$15.00
Sun-Dried Tomato Olive Tapenade
Our Sun-Dried Tomato Olive Tapenade is simply divine with its tangy and full-bodied flavor. The tomatoes are slow-dried in the sun and blended with just the right amount of herbs. We then add crushed Kalamata Olives to create this intensely deep flavored tapenade.$5.50 - $12.00
Tapenade Gift Tube
A perfect sampling of our most popular tapenade flavors packaged in a neatly arranged gift tube.$17.00Mannix Ground Vanilla Beans
$15.00
Mannix Vanilla Almond Vanilla
$15.00
Mannix Vanilla Coconut Vanilla
$15.00
Mannix Vanilla Double Strength - 100ml
$28.00
Mannix Vanilla Orange Vanilla
$15.00
Mannix Vanilla Sugar
$12.00